Navigating the RFP (Request for Proposal) process can be tough, but the right strategy and documentation will help you stand out and increase your chance of success getting onto an insurance panel.
I’m Neil from Supply Chain Connections, and I’m sharing my insights to help you avoid common pitfalls and craft winning RFP responses.
Read on to discover the 8 do’s and don’ts to ensure your next RFP submission shines.
5 things to do on your next Insurance RFP
1. Answer the questions directly
One of the most frequent errors in RFP responses is failing to address the questions directly and missing the point of the question. It’s a fine line between providing too little or too much information, but whatever you do, make sure you answer the question being asked. Make sure your responses are clear, concise, and directly related to what is being asked. Always keep the customer at the centre of your answers and consider offering different commercial models as options for the company to consider.
Tip: How to enhance your RFP
Include supporting documents like videos where relevant. These can provide additional context and value to your submission, making it more compelling.
2. Stand out with honesty and thoroughness
To ensure your RFP responses stand out, dedicate sufficient time to respond thoughtfully. Check your answers before submission to avoid errors and omissions.
3. Understand what the panel is looking for
When crafting your RFP, focus on the following essential components to catch the panel’s attention:
- Unique customer offering: highlight what sets you apart from other bidders. Use case studies to demonstrate your unique value and results.
- Addressing challenges: provide examples of how you handle geographical or capacity challenges that others might struggle with.
- Pre-RFP engagement: engage with the client before the RFP is released. This can help you understand the key issues the RFP is trying to address and whether the client is genuinely looking to switch suppliers or just fulfilling a compliance requirement.
4. Demonstrate supply chain mastery
Modern RFPs often require you to show that you proactively understand and manage your supply chain. Here’s how to demonstrate your capabilities:
- Evidence of supply chain management: provide details on your supply chain, including the number of suppliers and risk assessments.
- Regular supply chain reviews: document known or perceived risks and show how you manage them.
- Business continuity plans: include copies of your business continuity plans (BCPs) that cover core service disruptions, such as telephony or data outages.
5. Foster strong relationships
Building strong relationships plays a crucial role in successful supply chain solutions Here’s how to leverage relationship-building in your RFP process:
- Understand the business need: engage with the business owner to grasp the real business need beyond what is presented in the RFP. Understand what success looks like for them.
- Address performance challenges: if you are a current supplier, be aware of any performance issues and seek feedback regularly. Show that you are committed to continuous improvement.
- Showcase developments: regularly highlight new developments or changes that improve outcomes. Ensure those involved in managing the service are part of this process.
3 don’ts for your next RFP
Now you know what to do on your next RFP, here are 3 things you should avoid:
- Overpromising: don’t offer services you cannot deliver. Be honest about your capabilities. If you’re proposing a new service, clearly state your willingness to support the client with a suitable ramp-up period.
- Lack of supporting information: use appendices to provide additional information, especially for standard compliance questions.
- Ignoring pricing requirements: if you propose a different pricing model, include it as an additional offer while also providing the requested pricing.
Request for Proposal Dos and Don’ts
By following these dos and don’ts, you will significantly enhance your RFP responses, increasing your chances of success. Remember, the key is to be clear, honest, and proactive.
For tailored advice and support on your next RFP, contact Supply Chain Connections today. We’re here to help you navigate the complexities of the RFP process and secure your place on the panels you desire.
Contact Supply Chain Connections today and let us help you craft winning RFP responses!

